TL;DR
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
J.M. Smucker has introduced a refrigerated version of Uncrustables that can be stored in the fridge for up to five days, removing the wait for a frozen sandwich to thaw. Food Dive describes the brand as a $1 billion business; Smucker says the change could encourage trial and more frequent purchases, but has not provided sales forecasts for the new version.
J.M. Smucker has introduced a refrigerated version of Uncrustables that can be kept in the fridge for up to five days, giving consumers a ready-to-eat alternative to the brand’s traditionally frozen peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. The launch comes as Uncrustables has grown into a $1 billion brand, and Smucker is counting on the change to attract new buyers and prompt existing customers to eat the product more often.
The original frozen sandwiches typically take about 30 minutes to thaw, according to Food Dive’s report. The refrigerated version is intended to be eaten without that wait. Smucker senior vice president and general manager of frozen handheld and spreads Rebecca Scheidler told the publication that shoppers had asked the company for a solution that would let them eat a sandwich when they wanted it, rather than planning around thawing.
Developing the new option required changes to the existing recipe, Scheidler said. Smucker worked to keep the bread soft rather than stale or soggy during refrigeration and to prevent the peanut butter and jelly filling from seeping out. The company’s stated goal was to preserve the eating experience of the frozen product while making it available sooner.
Smucker’s consumer research points to potential demand, though it is not a sales forecast. The company found that 50% of people who had not bought Uncrustables said they would be more likely to purchase the product if they did not have to wait for it to thaw. Among existing users, 72% said they would eat it more often if a refrigerated option were available. The report does not specify when the research was conducted or give details about the survey sample.
A Faster Route to More Snack Occasions
The change targets a practical barrier in how consumers use the product: a sandwich stored in a freezer is not ready to eat immediately. With a refrigerated option, Smucker is aiming to make Uncrustables more convenient for people looking for a quick snack or lunch, while widening the occasions when existing customers might choose it.
That matters commercially because the brand is already a $1 billion business, and a larger customer base or more frequent purchases could support further growth. But the figures Smucker cited measure stated likelihood and intent, not completed purchases. They do not show how many consumers will actually buy the refrigerated version, or how much it might add to sales.
The release also gives Smucker another way to distinguish its offering as competitors enter the crustless sandwich category. Scheidler said the company welcomes competition as a way to grow the category, while presenting continued product development as a way to set Uncrustables apart. The refrigerated launch is one such product change; its effect on market share remains to be seen.
Products Worth Considering
Cuisinart ICE-70P1 2-Quart Ice Cream Maker with Countdown Timer
Instant Pot InstantChill Ice Cream Maker with Rolled Ice Cream Cold Plate, 2-Pint
Cuisinart ICE-100 1.5-Quart Automatic Ice Cream and Gelato Maker
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Freezer Staple to Fridge
Uncrustables launched at retail in 2000, after Smucker acquired the brand in 1999 and renamed a crustless sandwich product. The sandwiches have traditionally been sold frozen, a format that supports longer storage but requires consumers to plan ahead or wait for the product to thaw.
Smucker has previously sought growth through new flavors and a version containing 12 grams of protein, according to Food Dive. The company’s account of the brand’s early history traces the idea to a crustless peanut butter and jelly sandwich made for children. It was first marketed as The Crustless Wonder before Smucker acquired the business.
The category has attracted competitors. Food Dive reported that Smucker sued Trader Joe’s last year, alleging that the retailer’s crustless peanut butter and jelly sandwiches were an “obvious copycat” of Uncrustables. That characterization is an allegation in the lawsuit, not an independently established finding. The report does not give the case’s current status.
““We said, okay, if that’s the desire, what is it going to take for us to be able to deliver that immediate consumption need that they wanted, but without sacrificing the quality and the experience?””
— Rebecca Scheidler, speaking to Food Dive
Sales Impact Still Unmeasured
The available report does not provide sales figures for the refrigerated product, a forecast for its contribution to the brand, or a comparison of its price with the frozen sandwiches. It is also unclear how broadly the new option is available, whether it will be sold in all markets where frozen Uncrustables are offered, and whether the recipe or package differs by retailer.
Smucker’s consumer research describes how respondents said they might behave, rather than tracking purchases after launch. The report does not state the survey date, sample size, or methodology. It also does not provide further information on the company’s lawsuit against Trader Joe’s, so the legal dispute’s status cannot be determined from the source material.
Retail Availability and Repeat Sales
The next measures to watch are the refrigerated product’s retail availability and sales performance, including whether consumers who have not previously tried Uncrustables become buyers and whether existing customers purchase more frequently. Smucker has not announced a specific sales target or a timetable for reporting results from the launch.
More information about distribution, pricing, and performance may emerge through company updates or retailer listings. Until then, the release establishes the product’s storage window and Smucker’s rationale for launching it, but not whether the new format will materially increase the brand’s sales.
Key Questions
What changed with Uncrustables?
Smucker has introduced a refrigerated version designed to be stored in the fridge for up to five days, rather than requiring consumers to thaw the sandwich from frozen before eating.
How long did the frozen sandwiches take to thaw?
Food Dive’s report says frozen Uncrustables typically take about 30 minutes to thaw. The refrigerated option is intended to be ready to eat without that wait.
Why did Smucker develop a fridge-friendly version?
Smucker says consumers wanted to eat the sandwiches immediately instead of waiting for them to thaw. The company also cited research indicating that some non-buyers and existing customers might be more likely to purchase or eat Uncrustables if a refrigerated option were available.
Does the new option already have a proven sales impact?
The report does not provide sales results for the refrigerated version. Smucker’s cited figures describe consumer responses about purchase likelihood and intended frequency, not confirmed purchases or a measured increase in sales.
How much of the market has tried Uncrustables?
Scheidler told Food Dive that about half of consumers had not tried the brand. The report also says Smucker found that 50% of non-buyers surveyed were more likely to purchase if they did not have to wait for a sandwich to thaw; survey details were not provided.
Source: fooddive.com
